Opera Daily 🎶 — Peter Grimes
This week's Opera Daily features the English opera Peter Grimes by the contemporary British composer Benjamin Britten
👋 Hello to the new Opera Daily subscribers who have joined us this week. I hope you’re sitting on a comfortable couch with a warm beverage and enjoying your weekend. You can check out the complete Opera Daily archives and the playlist on YouTube for more selections. If you were forwarded this email by a friend, join us by subscribing here:
There is no clear answer as to why Peter Grimes is so popular. Some people believe that the opera’s popularity is due to its complex and suggestive storyline, while others believe that it is the result of Britten’s masterful composition.
Regardless of what you believe the reason is, there is no denying that the “Embroidery Aria” for soprano from Act 3 is one of the most beautiful moments in the opera.
Peter Grimes is about a small fishing community on the East Coast of England.
Peter Grimes (the title role sung by a tenor) is a fisherman, but the locals in the village see him as an outsider and don’t trust him. Renée Fleming is singing the role of Ellen Orford here, along with an excerpt of Nicole Car singing the same aria during a rehearsal from The Met.
This aria is a perfect example of word painting (a musical technique Britten used in his compositions that reflects the literal meaning of a song’s lyrics). Like embroidery work, the meandering tune you hear Renée (and Nicole) singing will feel like a needle and thread in motion.
🎧 Listening Example (6 minute listen): Renée Fleming singing “Embroidery Aria”, Benjamin Britten, Peter Grimes, London Symphony Orchestra, Sir Georg Solti, 1997
🎧 Listening Example (1 minute listen): Soprano Nicole Car singing an excerpt from Ellen Orford’s Act 3 aria, “Embroidery Aria” in an early dress rehearsal of Britten’s Peter Grimes at The Met, Nicholas Carter, conductor
On June 7th, 1945, Peter Grimes premiered at the Sadler’s Wells Theatre in London and is one of the greatest English operas of the 20th century.
The opera is set in a fictional village which is loosely based on Britten’s home town of Aldeburgh, a Suffolk seaside town. It is based on the narrative poem “Peter Grimes”, in George Crabbe’s book The Borough. Crabbe was also a native of Aldeburgh.
Peter Grimes is on trial in his village for the mysterious death of his apprentice. He is found not guilty but socially excluded by the villagers, except for a school teacher, Ellen Orford. Against the village’s advice, Peter Grimes takes on a new apprentice who accidentally falls over the edge of a cliff.
This aria above happens after Ellen finds the outfit she made for Peter’s apprentice washed up onshore. She knows what this means—that the boy is dead and the community will blame Peter for it. Ellen infers that the boy has died by singing, “Now my embroidery affords the clue, whose meaning we avoid.”
Want more?
“(Peter Grimes) is very close to my heart—the struggle of the individual against the masses. The more vicious the society, the more vicious the individual.” — Benjamin Britten
Britten’s music is modern, often dissonant sounding but always filled with beautiful melodies. Britten started composing as a child, and by 18, he’d written more than 700 pieces.
Many tenors have sung the title role in Peter Grimes, but Peter Pears and Jon Vickers are the most well-known for this incredibly complex character.
Tenor Peter Pears performed in the premiere in 1945. Below is the BBC telecast from 1969 of Peter Grimes with Peter Pears and the original Ellen Orford (Heather Harper) with Benjamin Britten conducting.
Grateful for your time and ears,
Michele
PS. Missed our last edition? We featured “Com'è gentil”, a tenor aria from Act 3 of the Italian opera Don Pasquale by Gaetano Donizetti.
❤️ Enjoyed this piece? Hit the heart to like it. It helps others find Opera Daily.
Full disclosure - I wrote my undergrad Senior Thesis on Montagu Slater's development of the libretto from Crabbe's original and how Britten changed Slater's libretto and then the meaning of it by his musical setting of it. Peter Grimes has held a special place in my heart for 40 years, especially the Vickers/Harper recording. I prefer Vickers in this role over Pears because he brings a lyricism to it, and a pathos, that are heart wrenching. He makes us think about how bad people are not wholly bad and good people are not wholly good and how soul crushing life can be (not least of which for orphans). But ... I LOVE that you wrote about Ellen's part. Heather Harper's performance of Ellen was my introduction to her singing. She is IMO one of the great British sopranos (along with Jennifer Vyvyan and Felicity Lott), and I've been a fan since. Her recording os Strauss' Four Last Songs and Orchestral Leider is a favorite.
Kudos on this one. I had a lot going on, did not feel 'in the mood for a more modern period opera that I don't know. Then clicked on your 'Embroidery in Childhood' selection and was blown away. Completely drawn in.