Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Daniel P Quinn's avatar

Pavarotti recorded Beethovens' In Questo Tomba Oscuro which is unforgettable and deeply moving that students could sing as well.

Expand full comment
Guy Stalnaker's avatar

Sadly, many voice teachers (mine included) do not tell their students that some of the works in the 24 Italian Songs and Arias come from actual operas of the 17th century. That is, the arias are part of an opera & that they fit within a larger narrative work with characters, emotions, etc. The great singers who still sing these songs and arias learn/know this and they bring all their craft to them. Pavarotti was one who performed these arias in recital. A great example is a recital one can fine on YouTube at the Brooklyn Academy of Music early in his career (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BPJisqcDgDg&list=PLNvlNmiC23ap6MZGghkDvFeZqwLE37rVM) and on Amazon (https://www.amazon.com/Luciano-Pavarotti-Recital-York-1973/dp/B0000019VI). In this recital the first THREE works are from the 24! A fascating glimpse of what these Song and Arias can become when approached with the right perspective. I wish that EVERY voice teacher would impress on their students their absolute seriousness as works of art (as they certainly were when they were written in the 17th century). I'll never forget hearing Pavarotti sing "Caro mio ben"!! What a revelation after having heard so many frestman voice students sing it (or attempt to sing it). Give those YouTube vidoes some time; you'll not regret it (only caveat is that the recording is by an audience member, I think, so that quality is lacking, but the sincerity of the performers is obvious).

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts